Contest Grading Guidelines
The highest score of grading is 200 points; judging criteria mainly consists of "Artistic Impression Point" (maximum 100 points) and "Technical Point" (maximum 100 points divided into 5 categories for 20 points).
In this contest, aquarist's skill of a long-term maintenance of layout is also in judges' great concern. Since the planted aquarium hobby involves various forms of life, we don't just appreciate the beauty of a layout shown right after its completion, we pay careful attention to observe how long the layout has been kept in a healthy condition.
In that context, the following aspects of layout were, especially, strictly screened by the judges. First, the use of emerged plants and house plants which hardly survive in the water becomes the subject of point deduction. In order to avoid misuse of plants in a layout, one needs not only the composition skill but a good deal of correct knowledge about aquatic plants. Moreover, it requires a higher level of technique to grow plants healthfully. These aspects of layout are judged under the criterion of "Creativity".
There was a debate over the use of very fine white cosmetic sand, such as Rio Negro sand. Due to the nature of this type of sand, excretions of fish and shrimps become more recognizable on white sad. The color of the sand turns more easily to a unpleasant greenish or blackish color because of the growth of algae and the spread of anaerobic bacteria inside an aquarium. It was pointed out that it's hardly kept brightly clean for a long period of time. Although the cosmetic sand used in the layout looks elegantly beautiful in the picture, the layout receives a tough evaluation from the judges.
The layouts were evaluated by 18 judges chosen internationally, and then, this year's world ranking was decided. The whole grading process was conducted impartially by the judges and so was the counting of scores by the contest committee. However, the evaluation of each judge primarily relies on his/her personal preference of the types of aquatic plant layout. It doesn't necessary become an absolute account of the layout.
Judging Criteria & Guidelines
ARTISTIC IMPRESSION POINT(Maximum 100 points)
Evaluate the beauty and sophistication as a piece of art.
TECHNICAL POINT
Creativity (Maximum 20 points)
The overall completeness of the layout and its originality are evaluated.
The use of house plants or emerged plants, which hardly survive under water, becomes a subject of point-deduction.
Composition / Arrangement of plants (Maximum 20 points)
Is the composition of the layout well developed?
Are the aquatic plants appropriately positioned within the aquascape?
Is there a balance within the layout in terms of the colors and shapes of aquatic plants?
Balance between the fish and the layout design (Maximum 20 points)
Creator’s choice of fish for his/her layout is evaluated.
Do the color, size, swimming method and ecology of the fish match the layout?
Natural atmosphere (Maximum 20 points)
Does the layout clearly tell you the creator’s idea of nature?
How is the methods and techniques that the creator uses to render a natural feel in his/her layout?
Aquatic plants’ conditions and Time Progress of layout (Maximum 20 points)
The condition of the aquatic plants in the layout is evaluated.
The time progress of the layout based on the types of plants used and their conditions are evaluated.
Is the layout maintainable over a long period of time?
RSS Feeds (RDF)
